I saw this show just last night, and the very first thing I wanted to do when I got home was sit down and write this review. I didn’t, only because it was 11:30 at night and I’d been up for nearly 20 hours. That just goes to show you how wonderful this show was; even soaked to the skin and more than 7 hours after the show ended, it was still all I could think about.
First of all, I’d just to give a shout out to the staff of the Walter Kerr theatre. They were all quite lovely whenever I encountered them; definitely more friendly than many of the other theatre staff I’ve met in the past. So A+ job to them, as well.
It took 3 flights of stairs to get to my seat, and I ended up being the first row on the third story, or the balcony. I wasn’t really prepared for that kind of view; we looked down on everything, and sometimes we had to lean over the railing to see what was going on because many of the lights were right in front of us. I don’t know what I expected, having paid less than $50 for my ticket, but it wasn’t that. Still, I could see everything, so it was great!
I’ll be the first one to admit that, before Tony season, I really didn’t care about this show at all. I thought it was a clever idea, but something about it just didn’t make me say, “Wow! I need to see that show.” Watching the Tony performance of “I’ve Decided to Marry You” (linked for your viewing pleasure) totally changed that. Still, I hadn’t even considered going to see it on my trip to New York until my mom’s boyfriend surprised me with tickets as an early Christmas present. And let me tell you, I’m so glad that he did.
The show was just incredible from start to finish. I usually cry at the overture of any show that I see (I just get overwhelmed with the emotion of seeing a live performance; I don’t really know how to explain it), but I didn’t have a chance to cry because I was laughing right from the start.
I absolutely can’t give enough praise to the two leading men. Bryce Pinkham, who plays Monty Navarro in the show, was absolutely not what I expected in the best of ways. He really plays up the physicality of the role from the moment he steps on stage; he leaps and jumps and twirls and does the most hilarious things with his facial expressions throughout the whole show. He played Monty as a lot more flamboyant than I expected, but it just worked.
And Jefferson Mays. JEFFERSON. MAYS. I think leaving it there would be enough. This amazing actor plays the majority of the D’Ysquith family (which includes Asquith D’Ysqith Jr., Lord Asquith D’Ysquith Sr., Lord Adalbert D’Ysquith, the Reverend Lord Ezekial D’Ysqith, Henry D’Ysquith, Lady Hyacinth D’Ysqith, Major Lord Bartholomew D’Ysquith, and Lady Salome D’Ysquith Pumphrey. That’s 8 characters, friends). He was just hysterical the whole time. One of my favorite parts was when he was singing “I Don’t Understand the Poor” as Lord Adalbert. During his first chorus, he sang the first line (“I don’t understand the poor”), then stopped the music, looked up at the balcony where I was sitting, and pointed at all of us, making faces the whole time. He then proceeded to put his hands around his mouth and shout-sing the rest of the chorus to us. I was literally crying from laughter.
The “I’ve Decided to Marry You” sequence was probably my favorite part of the show, followed closely by the “Poison in My Pocket” scene. They’re almost impossible to describe without giving away major plot points, so I’ll restrain myself. I laughed completely though both songs; they were just wonderful. “I’ve Decided to Marry You” was definitely better live than on any award shows, and it really solidified my liking for Catherine Walker as Phoebe D’Ysquith. I was a bit skeptical of her, only because it the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade performance, it seemed like she was trying too hard to imitate Lauren Worsham’s Phoebe. However, she was so much better during this performance, and I think that’s because she was putting her own spin on the role instead of trying to copy what someone else had done. Kudos to her.
After the show, I went outside to the stage door to see if they would come out to sign playbills. It took them about 20 minutes or so, but they did, and it was the best stage door experience I’ve ever had. They were all so apologetic because it was raining outside (although we were under a covered construction area, so it didn’t matter much). I was standing right by the door, so they all came to me either first or second.
The first one that came out was Bryce Pinkham, and I was absolutely taken aback by his normal speaking voice. In my head, I knew he wasn’t British, but I still thought “this is wrong” when he started speaking and sounded American. He signed my playbill, and I asked if I could take a picture with him, which he did. He was just a complete sweetheart the whole time, and he didn’t seem to mind that I was shaking like leaf.
Then Lisa O’Hare, who played Sibella Hallward, one of Monty’s two ladies, came out. She was also very nice, but a bit rushed. I really don’t blame her, because not only was it rainy and cold outside, but it was a two-show day, so she had to come back and do it all again later. Still, the fact that she came out at all was so nice of her, and she was perfectly lovely (and expectedly British!)
The last one to come out was Jefferson Mays, and I was more than a little starstruck. I babbled a bit, talking about how wonderful he was and how it was such an honor to meet him. We weren’t able to get a picture, but we did have a full conversation, and it was wonderful. He was so nice; he asked me where I was from, I told him “Worcester, Massachusetts,” and he said “Oh, Woostah!” It made my day. When he had to leave, he turned to us all and said “Thank you all so much for coming. I’m going home to take a nap!” which was just about the best way to leave, I think.
All in all, this was a wonderful show and an experience for the books. This musical deserves every ounce of praise it has gotten over the past year, and the Best Musical Tony couldn’t have gone to a better show. I’m already looking forward to (possibly) going to see it again in February!













